Defamation Aaron Chase Defamation Aaron Chase

Defamation And The Neutral-Reporting Doctrine: A Look At Fox News's Tactic To Outsmart Smartmatic

On February 4th, the election technology company Smartmatic USA filed a lawsuit alleging that Fox News and others defamed it by broadcasting false statements that Smartmatic was part of a conspiracy to rig the presidential election. Fox responded to the complaint by filing a motion to dismiss, arguing that it is immune from liability based on the “neutral-reporting doctrine.” What is the doctrine, will it end the suit, and is it even available to Fox?

Read More
Trademark, Trade Dress, Lanham Act Aaron Chase Trademark, Trade Dress, Lanham Act Aaron Chase

Ezaki Glico v. Lotte International: One Smart Cookie? Or Just A Useful One?

The Third Circuit recently decided one of the most significant cookie cases in recent memory. The court found that Pocky are not deserving of trade dress protection because their shape is functional, rather than indicative of their source. The court rejected a too-narrow construction of the limitations on trademark protection for fear of blurring the lines between patent and trademark protections.

Read More

JN Contemporary Art LLC v. Phillips Auctioneers LLC: A Slightly Forced Major Force Majeure Decision

In a decision with potentially significant repercussions for commercial contracts governed by New York law, a judge in the Southern District of New York appears to have opened the door to using force majeure clauses more broadly to excuse performance as a result of the pandemic.

Read More
Aaron Chase Aaron Chase

Lestage v. Coloplast Corp.: A Key Qui Tam Retaliation Scam Slam

The First Circuit recently affirmed a jury verdict awarding an employee more than $760,000 in damages resulting from her employer’s retaliation against her for filing a qui tam action against the employer and a key customer. The decision in Lestage v. Coloplast Corp. makes the first circuit the latest to hold that retaliation under the False Claims Act requires a “but for” showing of causation.

Read More
Aaron Chase Aaron Chase

Chavez v. Occidental Chem. Corp.: A Banana Flavored Toll House Recipe

In an opinion with significant ramifications for the plaintiffs' bar, the New York Court of Appeals yesterday recognized the tolling of statutes of limitation for absent class members stemming from class actions filed in other jurisdictions. The court also held that such tolling ceases as soon as the out-of-state class action is dismissed for any reason – including non-merits dismissals.

Read More